Verify the flowers. Use only positively identified fresh European black elderflowers (Sambucus nigra subsp. nigra) from a trusted, unsprayed food-use source away from traffic and contamination. Do not use unknown flowers, other species, or berries.
Prepare clean equipment. Clean the work surface, utensils, heatproof food-safe infusion vessels, straining cloth, and storage containers thoroughly. Arrange refrigerator space at 40°F (4°C) or below before cooking.
Inspect and trim. Count the required large flower heads before trimming. Gently shake them over a light-colored cloth, inspect for insects and dirt, and snip away green stems. Remove leaves, stray stem pieces, browned flowers, and debris. Do not rinse, following the published method for preserving aroma; reject contaminated material.
Prepare the lemons. Wash and dry the lemons. Use half for finely grated yellow zest and juice, avoiding white pith, and cut the other half into thin slices. Remove visible seeds.
Dissolve the sugar. Combine the measured base water and white granulated sugar in a saucepan. Heat while stirring until dissolved. Do not add the water intended for diluting individual glasses.
Simmer the syrup. Bring the solution to a boil, then simmer gently for 10 minutes. Remove from the heat, handling the hot pan and syrup carefully to prevent burns.
Add citrus and acid. Stir the lemon zest, lemon juice, and measured food-grade citric acid into the hot syrup. Measure the acid with level U.S. measuring teaspoons in either unit system; do not substitute an assumed gram equivalent.
Pour over the flowers. Put the trimmed flowers and lemon slices in a suitable heatproof container. Carefully pour the hot syrup over them and arrange the ingredients under the liquid as far as practical. Do not add water. For scaled batches, divide the ingredients proportionally among additional suitable vessels.
Refrigerate and infuse. Cover and place promptly in the refrigerator at 40°F (4°C) or below; do not wait on the counter until completely cold. Infuse for 48 hours from refrigerator placement, keeping it refrigerated throughout. Use smaller suitable containers for larger batches so the hot infusion does not overload the refrigerator.
Strain and measure. Drain through a fine-mesh strainer lined with clean muslin or doubled cheesecloth into a clean bowl. Let it drip through without forcing plant pieces through the cloth. Discard the flowers and lemon slices. Measure the actual strained volume; do not top up with water to reach a target yield.
Bottle and store cold. Transfer to clean bottles or jars, close, label with the preparation date, and refrigerate immediately. Use within a few weeks as directed by Extension, without treating this as a guaranteed expiration date. Freeze portions not needed promptly in freezer-safe containers with at least 1 inch (2.5 cm) headspace; thaw in the refrigerator. Never can or store this syrup at room temperature.
Dilute to serve. Mix one part concentrate with five parts cold still or sparkling water as a starting ratio, then adjust in the glass. Dilution water is separate from the base recipe. Discard syrup showing mold, unexpected fermentation, gas, leakage, swollen closures, or abnormal odor without tasting.